1

I would like to check how many block confirmations are needed to be considered confirmed? Previously there was an answer that suggested 30 blocks (~ 30 minutes) Is this the recommended number? I have also read that tendermint is going to be implemented on tezos which allows instant confirmation have this been implemented?

2

This depends on what assumptions one makes on the stake an attacker trying to revert a transaction/block has, on the exact question one asks, on the degree of confidence one would like to have, and on further assumptions about the behavior of the network... For a more detailed answer see this blog post: https://blog.nomadic-labs.com/analysis-of-emmy.html.

Suppose we're trying to answer this question: my transaction was included x blocks ago (that is, there are already x confirmations), can I now be sure the block with the transaction remains on the main chain? And suppose that the chain is healthy (all x blocks have no delay, that is, they come 1 minute one after the other). Then the numbers x of confirmations are as follows:

  • 3 confirmations, for 20% attacker stake
  • 5 confirmations, for 30% attacker stake
  • 12 confirmations, for 40% attacker stake

(These numbers were obtained with a similar analysis as in the blog post, even though they do not appear as such there.)

| improve this answer | |
  • So there is no arbitrary number to take note but depends on how much the attacker is willing to lose? – Vinnyson Aug 25 at 18:43
  • 1
    In the above scenario (that is, with a perfectly healthy chain), indeed, the attacker would need to double bake in order to revert the considered transaction/block, so it risks losing its deposit. However, another way to view it, from the user's perspective, is how "valuable" its transaction is: the more valuable it is, the higher should the user assume the attacker's stake is. (But that's subjective, I don't know how to derive concrete and meaningful values for the attacker's stake out of this intuition.) – Eugen Aug 25 at 20:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.